Das Zwischenranking nach 24 von 33 verkosteten Weinen aus 2004

BY IN News aus dem Priorat, Prioratführer, Prioratjahrgänge NO COMMENTS YET

Das Gesamtranking 2004

24 von 33 Weinen je 2 mal blind von uns beiden verkostet

 

Platz 24/24 (33)

Combier, Fischer, Gerin; Trio Infernal 1/3; Priorat – Torroja del Priorat; 2004 rot;

92+; 94 = 93+/100 Th.

94; 94 = 94/100 VP

93,5+/100 = 94/100

 

Platz 23/24 (33)

Saó del Coster; 04 per Saó del Coster; Priorat – Gratallops; 2004 rot;

93+; 94+ = 93,5++/100 Th.

95; 94 = 94,5/100 VP

94++/100 = 94/100

 

Platz 22/24 (33)

Marc Ripoll Sans; Closa Batllet; Priorat – Gratallops; 2004 rot;

94+; 96+ = 95++/100 Th.

92+; 94+ = 93++/100 VP

94++++/100 = 94/100

 

Platz 21/24 (33)

Mas Martinet; Martinet Bru; Priorat – Falset; 2004 rot;

94+; 95+ = 94,5++/100 Th.

94+; 94+ = 94++/100 VP

94,25++++/100 = 94/100

 

Platz 20/24 (33)

Mas Doix; Salanques; Priorat – Poboleda; 2004 rot;

93+; 95+ = 94++/100 Th.

96+; 97+ = 96,5++/100 VP

95,25++++/100 = 95/100

 

Platz 18/24 (33)

La Perla del Priorat; Clos Les Fites; Priorat – El Molar; 2004 rot;

96+; 96+ = 96++/100 Th.

96+; 96 = 96+/100 VP

96+++/100 = 96/100

Mas Garrian; Clos Severí; Priorat – El Molar; 2004 rot;

96+; 96+ = 96++/100 Th.

96+; 96 = 96+/100 VP

96+++/100 = 96/100

 

Platz 17/24 (33)

Capafons – Ossó; Masia Esplanes; Montsant – Falset; 2004 rot;

95+; 96+ = 95,5++/100 Th.

97+; 97 = 97+/100 VP

96,25+++/100 = 96/100

 

Platz 16/24 (33)

Piro de Matret; Carlets; Priorat – Falset; 2004 rot;

95+; 96+ Th.

97+; 97+ VP

96,25++++/100 = 96/100

 

Platz 14/24 (33)

Venus la Universal; Venus; Montsant – Falset; 2004 rot;

96+; 97+ Th.

97+; 96 VP

96,5++++/100 = 97/100

Celler Fuentes; Gran Clos; Priorat – Bellmunt del Priorat; 2004 rot;

97+; 98+ = 97,5++ Th.

96+; 95+ = 95,5++ VP

96,5++++/100 = 97/100

 

Platz 11/24 (33)

Sangenis I Vaque; Coranya; Priorat – Porrera; 2004 rot;

97+; 98+ = 97,5++ Th.

96+; 96+ VP = 96++ VP

96,75++++/100 = 97/100

Mas d´ en Gil; Clos Fontá; Priorat – Bellmunt del Priorat; 2004 rot;

98+; 98+ = 98++ Th

94+; 97+ = 95,5++ VP

96,75++++/100 = 97/100

Mas Doix; Doix – Costers de Vinyes Velles; Priorat – Poboleda; 2004 rot;

96+; 98+ = 97++/100 Th.

96+; 97+ = 96,5++/100 VP

96,75++++/100 = 97/100

 

Platz 10/24 (33)

Celler Cecilio; L´ Espill; Priorat – Gratallops; 2004 rot;

96+; 97+ = 96,5+/100 Th.

98+; 98+ = 98++ VP

97,25++++/100 = 97/100

 

Platz 9/24 (33)

Clos Mogador; Clos Mogador; Priorat – Gratallops; 2004 rot;

98+; 98+ = 98++/100 Th

97+; 99+ =98++/100 VP

98++++/100 = 98/100

 

Platz 8/24 (33)

Celler Fuentes; Cartus; Priorat – Bellmunt del Priorat; 2004 rot;

98+; 99+ = 98,5++ Th

97+; 99+ = 98++VP

98,25++++/100 = 98/100

 

Platz 6/24 (33)

Clos Mogador; Manyetes; Priorat – Gratallops; 2004 rot;

99+; 99+ = 99++/100 Th.

98+; 99+ = 98,5++/100 VP

98,75++++/100 = 99/100

Vall Llach; Vall Llach; Priorat – Porrera; 2004 rot;

99+; 99+ = 99++/100 Th.

98+; 99+ = 98,5++/100 VP

98,75++++/100 = 99/100

 

Platz 5/24 (33)

Vinyes Mas Romani (Bodegas Mas Alta); La Basseta; Priorat – La Vilella Alta; 2004 rot;

100; 99+ = 99,5++/100 Th.

98+; 99+ = 98,5++/100 VP

99++++/100 = 99/100

 

Platz 2/24 (33)

Cartoixa de Montsalvat; Montsalvat; Priorat – La Vilella Alta; 2004 rot;

100; 100 = 100/100 Th

98+; 99+ = 98,5++/100 VP

99,25++++/100 = 99/100

Combier, Fischer, Gerin; Trio Infernal 2/3; Priorat – Torroja del Priorat; 2004 rot;

99+; 100 = 99,5++/100 Th.

99+; 99+ = 99++/100 VP

99,25++++/100 = 99/100

Ester Nin I Llort; Nit de Nin; Priorat – Porrera; 2004 rot;

99+; 100 = 99,5++/100 Th.

98+; 100 = 99++/100 VP

99,25++++/100 = 99/100

 

Platz 1/24 (33)

Merum Priorati; Osmin; Priorat – Porrera; 2004 rot;

100; 100 = 100/100 Th.

98+; 100 = 99++/100 VP

99,5++++/100 = 100/100

So, what do you think ?